From Toxic Stress to Radical Resilience

Nonprofit leaders often carry a profound sense of purpose—but with it can come an equally profound weight. The emotional labor of serving vulnerable populations, responding to community crises, and managing limited resources can lead to more than just burnout. Increasingly, research suggests that many leaders are experiencing toxic stress and secondary trauma, which not only affects individual well-being but also permeates entire organizations.

Toxic stress isn’t just a bad day at work. It’s the body’s long-term response to sustained adversity without adequate relief or support. Unlike typical stress, which may subside after a deadline or crisis, toxic stress can lead to chronic health conditions, emotional dysregulation, and decreased cognitive functioning (Harvard Center on the Developing Child, 2023). Leaders in the nonprofit sector—particularly in helping professions—frequently encounter their own past traumas and are consistently exposed to the suffering of others. This repeated exposure can cause what’s known as secondary traumatic stress or vicarious trauma.

What’s more concerning is that this stress doesn’t stop with the individual. Organizations themselves can become what some experts call “trauma-organized.” Like a family system shaped by crisis, trauma-organized workplaces show symptoms such as poor communication, high turnover, frequent conflict, and reactivity rather than strategic action. These environments may unknowingly normalize overwork, martyrdom, and emotional suppression, all under the guise of mission-driven commitment.

So how can nonprofit leaders reverse this culture?

The path forward starts with self-awareness and emotional safety. Leaders must recognize that the work they do is not average—and therefore requires above-average care. Simple self-care strategies aren’t enough. Building a trauma-informed organization means designing daily rituals, staff norms, and leadership expectations that prioritize psychological safety, reflection, and regulation.

Strategies might include:

• Emotional safety planning for staff to prepare for and decompress after difficult experiences.
• Organizational rituals that mark loss or transition, creating space for grief and healing.
• Values-based leadership that explicitly models boundaries, healthy communication, and emotional intelligence.
• Institutional support, such as paid mental health benefits, peer support groups, and ongoing professional development around trauma and resilience.

Ultimately, the health of a nonprofit cannot exceed the health of its leaders. A culture of resilience doesn’t just happen—it must be cultivated intentionally and consistently. And when it is, the rewards are significant: stronger teams, better retention, improved services, and a mission carried forward by leaders who are both committed and whole.

Resources

Visit Your Path to Nonprofit Leadership Podcast episode 312 with Brett Loftis for more information on this important topic. 

Looking to expand your nonprofit leadership skills? PMA is here to help! Learn more about our unique programs designed specifically for advancing your nonprofit career. 

Let us guide you on your unique Path to Nonprofit Leadership. 

Connect with us to speak with one of our expert consultants.

Leave us a comment below! We would love to hear from you!