How Nonprofit Leaders Can Get the Compensation They Deserve

For too long, nonprofit leadership has been synonymous with personal sacrifice. Many executive directors and nonprofit CEOs carry the unspoken burden of accepting low pay, minimal benefits, and precarious job security, justified by a commitment to mission. But this mindset is not only outdated, it’s unsustainable.

The nonprofit sector often operates under a harmful "poverty mindset," the belief that passion should compensate for a lack of financial and organizational resources. This narrative undermines talented leaders, accelerates burnout, and weakens long-term impact. According to a study by the Center for Effective Philanthropy, 69% of nonprofit leaders report feeling underpaid, and 59% say the stress of the job affects their physical health. Leaders cannot drive meaningful change if they’re constantly on the verge of exhaustion or financial instability.

To build resilient organizations, leaders must begin by advocating for themselves. That starts with negotiating fair compensation packages, not just salary, but benefits, professional development opportunities, and realistic workloads. Nonprofit executives should also seek employment contracts that offer basic protections, such as severance terms and clear job expectations. These are not luxuries, they’re tools to ensure continuity, stability, and a foundation for sustained leadership.

Equally critical is transforming the role of nonprofit boards. Too often, boards are disengaged from day-to-day leadership needs, failing to support executives or take part meaningfully in fundraising. A reimagined board culture must include thorough orientation, clear expectations, and accountability measures, such as give/get policies and performance agreements. Boards must recognize they are not only fiduciaries, they are partners in building the infrastructure that allows leaders to thrive.

This shift requires courage, but it’s also deeply pragmatic. When executive leaders are supported and secure, they can focus on the mission, lead their teams effectively, and innovate. Funders and stakeholders should recognize that investment in leadership isn’t a distraction from impact, it’s a prerequisite for it.

As the sector grapples with retention challenges and growing demands, nonprofit leaders must move beyond survival mode. Fair compensation, board alignment, and employment protections aren’t perks, they’re the pillars of a professional, high-impact sector ready to meet today’s challenges and tomorrow’s opportunities.

Resources

Looking to expand your nonprofit leadership skills? PMA is here to help! Learn more about our unique programs designed specifically for advancing your nonprofit career. 

Let us guide you on your unique Path to Nonprofit Leadership. 

Connect with us to speak with one of our expert consultants.

Leave us a comment below! We would love to hear from you!